Find a custom cake maker in New York, NY

Find Custom Cake Makers in New York, NY

Find Custom Cake Makers in New York, NY

Confirm your location to see the best custom cake makers near you.
Zip code

Find Custom Cake Makers in New York, NY

Confirm your location to see the best custom cake makers near you.
Zip code

Top 10 custom cake makers in New York, NY

Clients agree: these New York custom cake makers are highly rated for knowledge, experience, communication, and more.
Cakesbyjovi

Cakesbyjovi

New on Fash
6+ years in business
Serves New York, NY
Hi I’m Jovi the owner/founder of CakesbyJoviNYC we are here to bring your special moments together through cake. We offer all occasion custom cakes catering to all of NYC and surrounding areas. Little about me I’m a certified Pastry Chef of 15 years who have oversee pastry programs at some of the best restaurants and bakeries in NYC (CraftNY, VallataNYC, Upland NY, Amy’s Bread, MamanNYC) just to name a few aside from that I have been doing cake for 17yrs .
BK Dough Studio

BK Dough Studio

5.0(1)
Serves New York, NY
Brianna C. says, "Chef Tanisha did an amazing job on my husband's birthday cake! I ordered it last min and it was the most delicious red velvet cake I had in a while!" Read more
Strokos Catering

Strokos Catering

5.0Exceptional(5)
27+ years in business
Serves New York, NY
Ericka S. says, "I have used Strokos catering for many years. I cannot say enough amazing things about their food. Absolutely delicious! Their menu is very diverse and can accommodate most requests. They are reliable and always on time. I would recommend them for any size event. We have used them for catering to groups of 20 to 200. The quality and level of service is never compromised. Try them. You will not be disappointed " Read more
Asia's Wedding Service (860) 970-7162

Asia's Wedding Service (860) 970-7162

New on Fash
2+ years in business
Serves New York, NY
At Asia’s Wedding Services, I offer specialized wedding officiant services in Connecticut. With a deep commitment to making your special day unforgettable, I bring personalized attention to every ceremony I conduct. Whether you're planning an intimate gathering or a grand celebration, my goal is to ensure your wedding is a reflection of your unique love story. With a focus on meaningful and memorable experiences, I am dedicated to providing exceptional service tailored to your needs. Let me help you create the perfect moment for your "I do." Please call or text (860) 970-7162
Pinckney Catering

Pinckney Catering

5.0(1)
1 hire on Fash
8+ years in business
Serves New York, NY
Stacy J. says, "From the beginning to the end Shawn was a pleasure to work with. He arrived ready and on time. The food was delicious and presentation exquisite. He is passionate about his craft and it shows. We would definitely hire him again and recommend him to everyone! Thanks for turning a special occasion into a celebration! " Read more
Tablecloth Bakery

Tablecloth Bakery

New on Fash
7+ years in business
Serves New York, NY
Tablecloth Bakery was founded in 2019 by my sister and I. What started as a passion project quickly grew into a full-fledged business with a steady stream of customers. Our mission is as simple as our tagline; we want to provide "something for every sweet tooth, craving and guilty pleasure". Beyond that, however, we see the real value we provide in the joy and connection our baked goods create. We are trusted with our customers’ most special occasions—birthdays, weddings, and milestones—and we do not take that trust lightly. Our work is proof of our commitment to excellence, and we strive to create meaningful, lasting experiences with every p
Emilyhomestylecatering

Emilyhomestylecatering

New on Fash
17+ years in business
Serves New York, NY
Well I started my business in 2009 it grew to 2025 I love to cook I started doing live events every where I go my food sold out every where I cater I had a booking wheather it be birthday party baby shower wedding I'm there
Haagen Dazs

Haagen Dazs

New on Fash
18+ years in business
Serves New York, NY
Our ice creams and sorbets are super-premium, just like our service: catered sundae parties custom cakes pre-packaged (individually wrapped) ice cream It's easy to work with us! Tell us the number of guests, your favorite flavors, and leave the rest to us. Our catering team sets up, custom makes sundaes, cleans up.
Alexander Food Service

Alexander Food Service

New on Fash
Serves New York, NY
At Alexander Food Service, we specialize in creating unforgettable culinary experiences for weddings, events, and personal occasions in Flushing, NY. Our expert team offers a range of services, including wedding and event catering, personal chef experiences, and delightful candy buffet setups. With a passion for pastry and cake making, we craft exquisite desserts that are sure to impress. Choose us for your next event and savor the exceptional flavors and personalized service that define our unique culinary offerings.
Bienvenida Catering & Private Chef

Bienvenida Catering & Private Chef

5.0Exceptional(5)
4+ years in business
Serves New York, NY
Vasilina K. says, "I have had the pleasure of working with Bianca for a variety of events, including baby showers, birthday parties, engagements, and weddings, and I can't recommend her highly enough! From start to finish, she’s consistently exceed expectations. What stands out most is her ability to craft a personalized menu that perfectly matches the theme and style of each event. Whether it's a whimsical baby shower or an elegant wedding, she takes the time to understand the vision and curate a selection that delights every guest. The food is always fresh, beautifully presented, and full of flavor — no detail is overlooked. Not only is she incredibly professional, but her passion for what she does shines through in every dish she prepares. I’ve received endless compliments from guests on the food, and I can always count on Bianca to elevate the occasion. If you're looking for top-notch catering that feels personal and special, look no further!" Read more

Your Cake Making questions, answered

Answers to commonly asked questions from the experts on Fash.

How much do custom cakes cost?

A custom cake costs $70 to $400 on average, depending on which design, flavor, and size you choose. Larger, complex cakes with 3 or more tiers cost $200 to $800 or more. 

Custom cakes are an excellent way to make special memories during a birthday party, anniversary celebration, or other event.

Does Costco do custom cakes?

You can order a custom design on a cake from Costco, but ther choices are extremely limited. Depending on the location, the bakery may only be able to write a few words in frosting or put a simple buttercream image like balloons or a cactus.

However, the following locations have more options for custom designs:

  • Walmart 
  • Publix
  • HEB
  • Baskin Robbins
  • Sam's Club
  • Whole foods
  • Safeway
  • Albertson's
  • Tour Les Jours

How far in advance should I order a custom cake?

You should order a custom cake at least 1 to 4 weeks before your celebration. The exact timeline for ordering a custom cake will depend on how popular the bakery is, whether it's a busy season, and how much staff they have.

Can I return a custom cake?

No, you typically can't retuan a cake once they hand it over to you for food safety reasons. However, some bakeries will offer a partial or full refund if there's something wrong with the cake.

How do I choose a custom cake maker?

You can find a great cake maker by following these steps:

  • Compare prices from at least three local bakeries or stores.
  • Read reviews specifically for custom cake makers on Fash and Google.
  • Look at pictures of their cakes from other customers.
  • Make sure they're able to make the cake by the time you need it.
  • Get a detailed quote in writing.

What questions should I ask cake makers?

Asking these questions can help you find a high-quality cake maker:

  • How long have you been making or decorating cakes?
  • Can you make the cake I want by this date?
  • Is this price for naked cakes or frosted cakes?
  • How large of a cake would you recommend?
  • What type of frosting and fillings do you have?
  • Can you print edible pictures on the cake?
  • Do you have a minimum price or fee?
  • Can I see pictures of cakes you've done with a similar design?
  • Do you make smash cakes? How mcuh do those cost?
  • Do you make sheet cakes? How big are they?

Reviews for New York custom cake makers

Recent success stories from people in the New York area.
Evelyn R.
Strokos has been our office go-to for the last 4 years. Food is always a hit and punctual, what we most love is that they provide all plates, napkins, utensils, serving utensils etc at no extra charge!
Strokos catering
Noel K.
Bianca is a kind and extremely talented chef ! Not only is she great at her craft, her smile and personality light up the room. She’s an informative chef that knows her stuff! The flavors in her dishes and small bites are balanced and well received by all of my guests. Don’t forget to book her for your sweet treats as she is double threat in the kitchen and can bake up your desserts as well!
Bienvenida Catering & Private Chef
Fe' C.
Professionalism Courteous Prices are within the range of other caterers. Wait Staff is dressed appropriately for the event Food presentation Communication: informing host of any issues/challenges
Ps Baking & Catering Services, Inc.
Leissel L.
Professional. Classy. Great tasting. Presentation ALWAYS beautifulfood. Good prices
Stacy's Kitchen
How Fash works
Search

Search, get cost estimates, contact pros, and book—all for free.

Compare

View profiles, read reviews, check qualifications, and see prices before hiring.

Hire

Ask questions, confirm their availability, and hire the right pro when you're ready.

New York cake makers & decorators by service