Find a custom cake maker near you

Find Custom Cake Makers near me

Find Custom Cake Makers near me

Confirm your location to see the best custom cake makers in Columbus.
Zip code

Find Custom Cake Makers near me

Confirm your location to see the best custom cake makers in Columbus.
Zip code

Top 10 custom cake makers near you

Clients agree: these custom cake makers are highly rated for knowledge, experience, communication, and more.
BB Sweets LLC

BB Sweets LLC

New on Fash
18+ years in business
Cincinnati, OH
Welcome to BB Sweets LLC, Cincinnati’s premier destination for exceptional catering and personalized culinary experiences. With a dedicated team of two passionate professionals, we specialize candy buffet setups, and exquisite pastry and cake creations. Whether you’re planning an intimate gathering or a grand celebration, our expertise ensures your event is memorable and delicious. At BB Sweets LLC, we bring your culinary dreams to life with creativity, precision, and unparalleled customer service. Let us make your next event sweetly unforgettable!
Jasmine Zuckerman

Jasmine Zuckerman

New on Fash
2+ years in business
Etna, OH
I turn 18 this summer, I have an associates degree in Business Management, I am currently going to Columbus State Community College for the Apprentice Culinary Program I have experience with baking, cake decorating, cooking, health focused cooking, and cooking for people with Celiac. I grew up in a family with multiple people with Celiac, diabetes, and other allergies I have had several restaurant cook positions and am looking for my next step
12 Gate Cupcakes

12 Gate Cupcakes

New on Fash
13+ years in business
Columbus, OH
I cater to all my customers need, and I stand behind my products. With my cakes I want every occasion to be remembered. Seeing the customercureaction when their vision comes to life.
Slappin On Wheels

Slappin On Wheels

New on Fash
Columbus, OH
Slappin on wheels is dedicated to Catering with flavor and love with a large variety of different foods and baked goods we ensuring high quality ingredients and pushing every limit to make sure are customers are satisfied . We aim to please at slappin on wheels 😃
Cooking With Eminence

Cooking With Eminence

New on Fash
Springfield, OH
At Cooking With Eminence, we transform every occasion into a memorable culinary experience. Based in Springfield, OH, our premier services include wedding and event catering, officiating weddings, and providing exquisite dessert and beverage displays . As a personal chef, we tailor each menu to meet your unique tastes and dietary needs. Whether it's an intimate gathering or a grand celebration, our commitment to quality and personalized service ensures that your event is both delightful and stress-free. Let us bring elegance and flavor to your next occasion.
Hattiehoggfats

Hattiehoggfats

New on Fash
16+ years in business
Columbus, OH
How do hog fats is eclectic soul, Food catering restaurant? catering to all different ethnic groups from one to 1000 we meet all catering needs personal chefs birthday parties Teas brunches
Mink Cook

Mink Cook

New on Fash
2+ years in business
Columbus, OH
I coik and bake and i have someone to assist if need be. And i can prepare many dishes and specialize in pastries. I love to make and create creative dishes and work with food. I have over 17 years in food industry and worked in 15 kitchens and was a chef apprentice. I am 46 and since i was 11, i been cooking.
Options Carry-Out

Options Carry-Out

New on Fash
4+ years in business
Cincinnati, OH
Welcome to Options Carry-Out, Cincinnati’s premier choice for all your culinary and event planning needs! With an experienced team, we specialize in bartending, wedding and event catering, personal chef services, pastry chef and cake making, and comprehensive event planning. Whether you’re hosting an intimate gathering or a grand celebration, our dedicated duo ensures impeccable service and unforgettable experiences. Let us handle the details while you savor every moment. Make your next event extraordinary with Options Carry-Out!
Rustinas Catering Llc

Rustinas Catering Llc

5.0(1)
3+ years in business
Etna, OH
Brian S. says, "Great quality and service!!!! Recommend highly!! The food was absolutely amazing!!! Everything was fresh and the cakes were moist and delicious!!" Read more
Minister Of All Occasions LLC

Minister Of All Occasions LLC

New on Fash
14+ years in business
Bratenahl, OH & Online
At Minister of All Occasions LLC, based in Bratenahl, OH, we specialize in turning your wedding dreams into reality. With a dedicated team of six expert professionals, we offer a comprehensive suite of services, including exquisite wedding invitations, delectable cakes, top-notch catering, and stunning floral arrangements. Our skilled officiants and decorators ensure every detail is perfect, while our seasoned wedding planners handle all the logistics, allowing you to relax and enjoy your special day. Trust us to craft unforgettable moments for your cherished occasions.

Your Cake Making questions, answered

Answers to commonly asked questions from the experts on Fash.

How much do custom cakes cost?

A custom cake costs $70 to $400 on average, depending on which design, flavor, and size you choose. Larger, complex cakes with 3 or more tiers cost $200 to $800 or more. 

Custom cakes are an excellent way to make special memories during a birthday party, anniversary celebration, or other event.

Does Costco do custom cakes?

You can order a custom design on a cake from Costco, but ther choices are extremely limited. Depending on the location, the bakery may only be able to write a few words in frosting or put a simple buttercream image like balloons or a cactus.

However, the following locations have more options for custom designs:

  • Walmart 
  • Publix
  • HEB
  • Baskin Robbins
  • Sam's Club
  • Whole foods
  • Safeway
  • Albertson's
  • Tour Les Jours

How far in advance should I order a custom cake?

You should order a custom cake at least 1 to 4 weeks before your celebration. The exact timeline for ordering a custom cake will depend on how popular the bakery is, whether it's a busy season, and how much staff they have.

Can I return a custom cake?

No, you typically can't retuan a cake once they hand it over to you for food safety reasons. However, some bakeries will offer a partial or full refund if there's something wrong with the cake.

How do I choose a custom cake maker?

You can find a great cake maker by following these steps:

  • Compare prices from at least three local bakeries or stores.
  • Read reviews specifically for custom cake makers on Fash and Google.
  • Look at pictures of their cakes from other customers.
  • Make sure they're able to make the cake by the time you need it.
  • Get a detailed quote in writing.

What questions should I ask cake makers?

Asking these questions can help you find a high-quality cake maker:

  • How long have you been making or decorating cakes?
  • Can you make the cake I want by this date?
  • Is this price for naked cakes or frosted cakes?
  • How large of a cake would you recommend?
  • What type of frosting and fillings do you have?
  • Can you print edible pictures on the cake?
  • Do you have a minimum price or fee?
  • Can I see pictures of cakes you've done with a similar design?
  • Do you make smash cakes? How mcuh do those cost?
  • Do you make sheet cakes? How big are they?

Reviews for Columbus custom cake makers

Recent success stories from people in the Columbus area.
How Fash works
Search

Search, get cost estimates, contact pros, and book—all for free.

Compare

View profiles, read reviews, check qualifications, and see prices before hiring.

Hire

Ask questions, confirm their availability, and hire the right pro when you're ready.